At Your Keys Real Estate, we pair deep local knowledge with a thoughtful, client-first approach to help you find the perfect Key West home. Whether you’re dreaming of a historic Old Town cottage or a modern island retreat, you’ll find design, location, and lifestyle in every property we represent. With a focus on service, transparency, and island charm, our team guides buyers through every step of the journey with confidence and care. From first showings to final closings, Your Keys delivers a seamless, elevated experience—because finding your place in paradise should feel effortless. Let’s start your journey today.
YOUR KEYS
YOUR KEYS
Experience the best of island living with Your Keys Vacation Rentals and Your Keys Real Estate. Whether you’re planning a short-term stay in a charming cottage or ready to buy your dream home by the sea, our dedicated team provides the expertise and personal touch you need. Enjoy a seamless transition from unforgettable getaways to owning your own slice of paradise.
Your Trusted Team for Your Keys Real Estate
From finding the perfect home to managing it with care, Your Keys Real Estate offers a full-service approach to buying, selling, and investing in the Lower Keys. Led by Broker Richard Patten and backed by our in-house vacation rental and property management team, we provide the local insight, professionalism, and support you need every step of the way.
Anywhere from low six figures for a small condo to north of $10M for a waterfront estate. Single-family homes inside Key West city limits start around $850K to $1M for a smaller New Town place and go up fast from there. Old Town historic and anything with water access is its own much-pricier category.
Mostly flat right now. The big run-up from 2020-2023 cooled, and the market has been more or less sideways with normal seasonal noise. Luxury above $2M slowed the most. Old Town historic and conch houses are holding value better than condos.
You can’t build more island. Everything you see was built decades ago, the historic district controls what gets built today, and demand from buyers who can work remotely never stopped after the pandemic. Stack those up and Key West per-square-foot prices stay near the top of every Florida ranking.
Sometimes. Inventory is thin. You’re usually looking at smaller New Town places, a two-bedroom condo if you’re lucky, or something that needs work in the historic district. Renovation status matters a lot at that price. Don’t expect water views or modern finishes under a million.
Bahama Village if you want to be inside the city, parts of Midtown after that. Across the bridge on Stock Island is cheaper still, with a working waterfront vibe and some industrial neighbors. Real deals there for buyers who don’t need a Duval Street zip code.
Higher than most. Per square foot, Key West sits at or above Miami Beach and well above Naples or Sarasota. Only Palm Beach island and a couple of specific stretches of Miami Beach reliably cost more.
